Prepare to be amazed by the story of John Bernard Sutton, the mastermind behind Sudbury's iconic arena!
Sutton, a local architect, left an indelible mark on the city's landscape with his designs, including the beloved Sudbury Community Arena. However, this arena, which has served as a community hub for generations, is facing an uncertain future. With its days numbered, it's time to delve into the fascinating history behind its creation.
The Legacy of John Bernard Sutton
Sutton's architectural prowess extended beyond the arena. He designed various buildings that still stand today, such as the Copper Cliff Library, a testament to his modern and functional approach. However, it's the Sudbury Community Arena that truly showcases his talent.
The Arena's Journey: From Concept to Reality
The Civic Auditorium Planning Committee, in 1946, unanimously chose Sutton to lead the project alongside engineer H.H. Angus. The committee's decision to hire a local architect proved pivotal, allowing for seamless collaboration. Sutton's design impressed, with the ice surface built below street level, a first for Canada but a successful innovation adopted from arenas in the US.
A Work of Art: Sutton's Vision
In 1948, Sutton presented a scale model of the proposed civic center, described as a true work of art. The building was envisioned as a modern, state-of-the-art structure, equipped with every facility to serve the public. However, the project faced challenges, with initial funding falling short, leading to a scaled-back design and the cancellation of a community hall.
A Frantic Race Against Leaks
Despite delays due to over a thousand leaks in the ice-making apparatus, the arena finally opened in late 1951. The opening game between the Montreal Canadiens and Sudbury Wolves marked a historic moment. However, the arena's journey was not without setbacks, with issues in the cooling system and ongoing maintenance needs.
A Lasting Legacy, But for How Long?
Despite its age and deteriorating condition, the Sudbury Community Arena has defied expectations, surpassing the average lifespan of similar arenas. However, its future is uncertain, with plans to replace it with a new downtown event center by 2028. Unless a private investor steps in, the arena's fate is sealed, and its demolition will cost the city an estimated $5 million.
Sutton's Other Contributions
Beyond the arena, Sutton's designs include the INCO Employee's Club, a striking art deco structure, and the Jackson and Barnard Funeral Home. He also designed a high school, now known as Sudbury Secondary, and the Sudbury-Algoma Sanatorium, now Kirkwood Place, a regional health center. His work extended beyond Sudbury, with a public school in Massey and a fire hall in Ferguson Street.
A Fading Legacy, A Call to Action
As we bid farewell to the Sudbury Community Arena, it's important to recognize the man behind its design. John Bernard Sutton's legacy lives on through his architectural masterpieces, but it's up to us to ensure his story is not forgotten.
And here's the controversial part: Should we preserve these architectural landmarks, or is it time to make way for modern developments? What do you think? Share your thoughts in the comments!
